• Front cover view of Everything You Want Me To Be by Mindy Mejia centered on a neutral light gray background. Creasing and chipping to the book cover corners.
  • Back cover view of Everything You Want Me To Be by Mindy Mejia centered on a neutral light gray background. Crease in the top right corner near the spine.
  • Close-up spine view of Everything You Want Me To Be by Mindy Mejia centered on a neutral light gray background. Spine is square and shows no creasing.
  • Close-up page edge view of Everything You Want Me To Be by Mindy Mejia centered on a neutral light gray background. Top few pages are creased on the corners. The remaining pages lay flat.
1 4

Mindy Mejia |

Everything You Want Me To Be by Mindy Mejia

Everything You Want Me To Be by Mindy Mejia

$13.00 USD
$13.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.
🎧
Listen on Libro.fm
Support Independent Bookstores

Digital fulfillment provided by our partner, Libro.fm. Prices for our digital collection are managed by our partner, Libro.fm, to ensure you receive the best independent bookstore rate and membership benefits.

  • Ships within 1–2 business days. Carefully packaged for safe delivery.

A Mindy Mejia Psychological Crime Thriller of Small-Town Secrets and Multiple Lives

In the rural town of Pine Valley, Minnesota, high school senior Hattie Hoffman is found brutally stabbed to death in an abandoned barn. To her parents and classmates, Hattie was a quiet, dutiful daughter and star student, but her murder reveals a young woman who expertly crafted different identities for everyone around her.

Told through three alternating perspectives—Hattie's final months leading up to her death, the local sheriff investigating the crime, and her married high school English teacher with whom she carried on a clandestine affair—the story unravels small-town obsession, ambition, and betrayal.

Why You’ll Love This Book

Mindy Mejia constructs a tight, atmospheric psychological mystery driven by complex character studies and shifting timelines. A compelling choice for readers who enjoy small-town crime stories and psychological suspense.

Edition & Specifications

Publisher: First Pocket Books

Pages: 

Format: Paperback

Publication Date: 2018

ISBN: 9781982113568

Condition Note:

Condition & Grading Guide

How We Grade Our Books

  • 📸 True-to-Life Photos: For all vintage and pre-loved books, the photos on the page are of the exact physical copy on our shelf. Brand-new books feature official publisher cover art.
  • New: Direct from the publisher; immaculate, unread condition.
  • Like New: Pristine condition with minimal to no shelf wear; looks unread.
  • Very Good: Lightly read with minor shelf wear or light cover creasing. Pages are clean, crisp, and unmarked with a tight binding. (Our baseline standard for pre-loved books.)
  • Good: A well-loved reading copy with visible shelf wear or page aging, but fully intact and structurally sound.

Packaging & Shipping

Shipping Details & Delivery Speeds

  • FREE Domestic Shipping: Standard shipping is free on all U.S. orders $50+.
  • Standard Flat-Rate Shipping: Orders under $50 ship at flat, weight-based rates starting at $6.99.
  • Tracking Included: You will receive an automated tracking link via email as soon as your order is packed and labeled.
  • Expedited Shipping Available: Need it faster? UPS 2nd Day Air is available at checkout (ships out the next business day).

Read our full shipping policy here

The Fehmerling Guarantee

Our Guarantee & Return Policy

  • 14-Day Returns: Unread books and unopened tea packages can be returned within 14 days of delivery.
  • Damaged in Transit? If your shipment arrives damaged or incorrect, email us within 72 hours of delivery scan at customerservice@fehmerlingbooks.com. We’ll evaluate it immediately and provide a prepaid return label and replacement or full refund.
  • Hassle-Free Support: To start a return, simply email us with your order number.

Read our full return & refund policy here

View full details
$13.00 USD
$13.00 USD
Sale Sold out

Curate Your Perfect Reading Night

September 24, 2025

An Autumn Comfort for a Deadly Performance

Discover the final pairing in our Fragmented Mind collection. We're exploring the deceptive world of Mindy Mejia's "Everything You Want Me To Be" with the cozy, familiar warmth of Autumn Vibes Cinnamon Hazelnut Black Tea. Find out why this comforting brew is the perfect companion for a story built on secrets and lies.
Read Full Article
September 01, 2025

A Reader's Guide to The Fragmented Mind: Psychological Thrillers

Ready to question everything? Dive into our September collection of psychological thrillers. This guide will help you find the perfect story of paranoia and suspense, from domestic thrillers to tales with unreliable narrators.
Read Full Article
October 01, 2025

What's Your Architectural Nightmare? A Reader's Guide to Finding Your Perfect Spooky Read

This October, the house is haunted, the home is a trap, and the mind is a maze. Step inside 'The Architecture of Fear' and discover which blueprint holds your perfect atmospheric horror read.
Read Full Article
12